01What happened

The story, straight

The accusation stems from a video clip of Seohyun and fellow SNSD member Hyoyeon dancing to Hyoyeon's 2021 song 'Second' while Seohyun appears to flip through a magazine in the background.

Seohyun from Girls' Generation is getting roasted on X because someone posted a clip claiming she was 'making faces' at TWICE's Jihyo. The video is Hyoyeon dancing to her own song 'Second' while Seohyun's in the background flipping through a magazine. The post called it 'pure bitterness' but the clip doesn't actually show Jihyo in frame — it's vibes-based prosecution.

02Spread timeline

Where it actually started

2026-06-18Origin
User posts clip accusing Seohyun of showing 'pure bitterness' toward Jihyo, claims SONEs are deleting the video.X user posts the clip and accuses Seohyun of hating on Jihyo, says fans are scrubbing it
source
2026-06-18
Koreaboo publishes article covering the controversy and the fan backlash against Seohyun.Koreaboo picks it up and writes it up as a full story
source

03Source receipts

Every claim, linked

KoreabooKoreaboo article detailing the X post, the video clip context (Hyoyeon dancing, Seohyun in background), and fan accusations of 'pure bitterness' toward Jihyo
primarysearchreceipt

04What's solid, what isn't

What's solid and what isn't

Confirmed
  • Seohyun and Hyoyeon appeared in a video clip together where Hyoyeon danced to 'Second' and Seohyun flipped through a magazine in the background.
  • An X user posted the clip claiming Seohyun showed 'pure bitterness' toward TWICE's Jihyo.
Disputed
  • Whether Seohyun's expressions were directed at Jihyo or anyone at all — the clip doesn't show Jihyo in frame.
  • Whether SONEs actively deleted the original video as claimed by the poster.
Developing
  • Neither Seohyun, SM Entertainment, nor JYP have commented on the controversy.

05Why it matters

The editorial take

This is a textbook K-pop fan-war escalation: a decontextualized clip, an interpretive leap, and immediate pile-on dynamics. Girls' Generation and TWICE are both under SM and JYP respectively, and inter-generational fandom tensions have intensified as third-gen groups age into legacy status while fourth-gen groups dominate discourse.

Classic kpop stan behavior — a 5-second clip with no context becomes a federal case. Seohyun's been in the industry for 16 years and the charge is 'she looked at a magazine too aggressively.' The SNSD-TWICE dynamic is the real story here: older groups can't exist online without getting re-litigated by newer fandoms.